PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-19T08:45:33Z

I've updated the ticket with the additional information. Feel free to add yourself as a watcher to see progress.

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-19T04:11:20Z

Dieter MetzlerPayPal checkout works fine when the product has no taxcategorie, but the following error appears when I add a taxcategorie to a product:

2019-04-09 15:02:37.172 ERROR [ajp-nio-8009-exec-15][HttpConnection:153] Response code: 400     Error response: {"name":"VALIDATION_ERROR","details":[{"field":"transactions[0].amount","issue":"Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"}],"message":"Invalid request - see details","information_link":"https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors","debug_id":"xxxxxxxxx"}
2019-04-09 15:02:37.177 WARN  [ajp-nio-8009-exec-15][PortalImpl:6899] response-code: 400        details: name: VALIDATION_ERROR message: Invalid request - see details  details: [{_  "field": "transactions[0].amount",_  "issue": "Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"_}]     debug-id: xxxxxxxxxx information-link: https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors [Sanitized]
response-code: 400      details: name: VALIDATION_ERROR message: Invalid request - see details  details: [{_  "field": "transactions[0].amount",_  "issue": "Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"_}]     debug-id: c3d4f7d8eef88 information-link: https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors [Sanitized]
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalRESTException.createFromHttpErrorException(PayPalRESTException.java:72)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.execute(PayPalResource.java:431)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.configureAndExecute(PayPalResource.java:295)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.configureAndExecute(PayPalResource.java:228)
        at com.paypal.api.payments.Payment.create(Payment.java:149)
        at

I have testet it with the latest Liferay Commerce Bundle Liferay Portal CE 7.1 GA3 and Liferay Commerce 1.1.3 (Bundled with Tomcat)
Do I have a mistake in my configuration or is this a known bug.

Any help is appreciate.

Kind regards

Dieter

Dieter,
For me the PayPal transaction is not successful even if no Tax is configured for the products.
Still it gives me the same error that you reported.

Can you brief me about your Tax configurations?
Thanks in Advance

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-19T04:10:07Z

For me the PayPal transaction is not successful even if no Tax is configured for the products.
Still it gives me the same error that you reported.

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-19T04:00:09Z

I have a downloaded source code of liferay commerce in which I see below method code in
commerce-payment-method-paypal/src/main/java/com/liferay/commerce/payment/method/paypal/internal/PayPalCommercePaymentMethod.java

private Amount _getAmount(
        CommerceOrder commerceOrder, CommerceCurrency commerceCurrency) {

        Amount amount = new Amount();

        amount.setCurrency(StringUtil.toUpperCase(commerceCurrency.getCode()));

        Details details = new Details();

        details.setShipping(
            _payPalDecimalFormat.format(commerceOrder.getShippingAmount()));
        details.setSubtotal(
            _payPalDecimalFormat.format(commerceOrder.getSubtotal()));

        amount.setDetails(details);

        amount.setTotal(_payPalDecimalFormat.format(commerceOrder.getTotal()));

        return amount;
    }

Here we can see that only shipping info and subtotal is set in the Details object which is being set in the Transaction object (_getTransactions method). Hence the code to set the Tax amount is not written.

I checked the latest code on GitHub & found that the code has been updated in _getAmount method but Tax is still not taken care:

https://github.com/liferay/com-liferay-commerce/blob/7.1.x/commerce-payment-method-paypal/src/main/java/com/liferay/commerce/payment/method/paypal/internal/PayPalCommercePaymentMethod.java

private Amount _getAmount(CommerceOrder commerceOrder)
       throws PortalException {

       Amount amount = new Amount();

       CommerceCurrency commerceCurrency = commerceOrder.getCommerceCurrency();

       amount.setCurrency(StringUtil.toUpperCase(commerceCurrency.getCode()));

       amount.setTotal(_payPalDecimalFormat.format(commerceOrder.getTotal()));

       return amount;
   }

This is a big issue. Incomplete code is released. For me none of the PayPal transactions are successful.

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-15T14:32:38Z

Hi Dieter, thanks for reporting. We're looking into it: https://issues.liferay.com/browse/EMP-26

RE: PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-15T14:08:00Z

Today I have downloaded and installed the new Liferay Commerce Version 1.1.4 (Liferay Portal CE 7.1 GA3 and Liferay Commerce 1.1.4 (Bundled with Tomcat)) and hoped the Bug was resolved, but sadly still the same error in the new Version.

Do someone knows a useful workaround to use Liferay Commerce with Paypal and taxes?

Thanks in advance for guidance.

PayPal Checkout Problem when adding Taxcategorie

2019-04-09T15:21:23Z

PayPal checkout works fine when the product has no taxcategorie, but the following error appears when I add a taxcategorie to a product:

2019-04-09 15:02:37.172 ERROR [ajp-nio-8009-exec-15][HttpConnection:153] Response code: 400     Error response: {"name":"VALIDATION_ERROR","details":[{"field":"transactions[0].amount","issue":"Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"}],"message":"Invalid request - see details","information_link":"https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors","debug_id":"xxxxxxxxx"}
2019-04-09 15:02:37.177 WARN  [ajp-nio-8009-exec-15][PortalImpl:6899] response-code: 400        details: name: VALIDATION_ERROR message: Invalid request - see details  details: [{_  "field": "transactions[0].amount",_  "issue": "Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"_}]     debug-id: xxxxxxxxxx information-link: https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors [Sanitized]
response-code: 400      details: name: VALIDATION_ERROR message: Invalid request - see details  details: [{_  "field": "transactions[0].amount",_  "issue": "Transaction amount details (subtotal, tax, shipping) must add up to specified amount total"_}]     debug-id: c3d4f7d8eef88 information-link: https://developer.paypal.com/docs/api/payments/#errors [Sanitized]
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalRESTException.createFromHttpErrorException(PayPalRESTException.java:72)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.execute(PayPalResource.java:431)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.configureAndExecute(PayPalResource.java:295)
        at com.paypal.base.rest.PayPalResource.configureAndExecute(PayPalResource.java:228)
        at com.paypal.api.payments.Payment.create(Payment.java:149)
        at