Liferay 7.2: DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameter

RE: Liferay 7.2: DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameter

2019-08-02T16:10:51Z

I see -- hmm. Well, the next thing I would try then is comparing the DefaultFriendlyURLMapper from 6.1 portal source to the version from 7.1 or 7.2. Might be an oversight on Liferay's part tha tyou can report to them, but temporarily fix with a custom mapper. If you do have a look and see something, can you let me know? (I've added checking myself to the list, but there are a lot of things ahead of it -- especially for a Friday! )

RE: Liferay 7.2: DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameter

2019-08-02T15:21:54Z

Yeah, in Liferay 6.1.1 the p_r_p-version of the parameter isn't shown when using DefaultFriendlyURLMapper.

For instance: https://www.cypax.dk/produkter/-/category/vis/BCDHEXSwitch

Here "vis" and "BCDHEXSwitch" are public render paramters.

RE: Liferay 7.2: DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameter

2019-08-02T14:41:37Z

Hi Lars,

I'm not sure if you can get rid of the p_r_p. I have used public render parameters in multiple solutions since the 7+ architecture has started. When I have them as regular (non public) render parameters, then the mappings work as expected. In all of my cases though, as soon as I promote them to be public, they start showing up in the url. I never dug into the source to validate why, but I also assumed that it was because they needed to live in the higher requests objects (the original request) so that they could be visible to all plugins on the layout.

I can't remember in 6.2 (or 6.1 for that matter) ... are you saying that in your 6.1 installation the p_r_p doesn't show in the url?

Liferay 7.2: DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameter

2019-08-02T11:02:32Z

Hi,

I'm still working on our 6.1.1 to 7.2.0 update.

Now I've run in to a slight issue with DefaultFriendlyURLMapper and public-render-parameters. While trying to fix it I noticed that there's the exact same issue on this site.

Take a look at this URL: https://liferay.dev/blogs/-/categories/39286915?p_r_p_resetCur=true&p_r_p_categoryId=39286915

Note that 39286915 is repeated becuase it's a public render parameter. That didn't happen in Liferay 6.1.1.

As far as I can tell p_r_p_-version isn't actually needed, the public render paramter seems to work without it.

Is this a bug in 7.2.0, or needed for some technical reason?
I guess I have to implement my own FriendlyURLMapper to get rid of it?